I cannot believe that Raw and Smackdown are produced by the same company. I just can’t. How can one show be so abysmally bad — and God/Allah/Buddah/Satan/alien god bless Sam for watching this shitness — and one not be? And look, this was the weakest Smackdown since the draft, but it still wasn’t terrible. The bad stuff simply constituted segments that didn’t quite work. The good stuff — Edge/Jeff Hardy was really good, and the people bought it big — was worth watching. It’s all I fucking ask. I know not every week is going to be great; just don’t insult me. I’ve been watching since I was 5, and now I kind of feel like the idiot, and not the other way around.
I was mulling seeing “Extreme Rules” because Edge/Hardy ladder match will be good, and Jim Ross did such a great fucking job putting over the history and significance of this, that these two men made their names against each other 10 years ago in tag team ladder matches. And now they battle each other over the world strap. Holy fucking shit, that’s so simple that is makes me weep just a little. So simple and so effective. I also think Punk/Umanga will be good, even if they did just kind of throw the strap into this thing for no good reason. I mean, Umanga just comes charging out with a strap, and suddenly it’s on. But whatever. Then they go and add Santino/Vickie hog pen match, and I’m out. No buying this. Not stealing this. They could bring 1989 Flair and Steamboat from the past into this show and have them fight, and I wouldn’t buy it. Could you imagine the ending this company would book?
Back to Umanga… I hated the promo. He was much better when he didn’t talk, and yeah, I know characters must evolve. But this was way, way, way, WAY too early for him to talk. And so much for him being a savage, since he put sentences together quite swimmingly. But anyway, Punk/Umanga, I’m fine with this otherwise.
John Morrison’s push continues, and he and Cryme Tyme finished off WGTT and … Ricky Ortiz? Another phantom switch as he’s a HEEL now. Actually, that’s better for him because he was never getting over as a face. But OK, Morrison gets the pin with the starship coyote, or whatever that thing’s called, so let’s move him up already.
There was a Rey Jr. promo that began as a trainwreck but then turned into a pretty damn good piece. He put over how important the IC belt is to him, and that he wants to continue the strap’s Hispanic heritage with Morales, Santana, and Eddy. He also talked about why masks are important to luchadores, and it was a dumbed down answer, but at least it took a stab at explaining why he wears a hood. Obviously foreshadows putting his mask up against Jericho down the road, which is a some decent plant seeding I don’t normally expect from a WWE writing team.
One big complaint with the Rey interview. He made a point about how he’s done with Jericho and wants to give other guys a crack at the belt. Two segments later, Teddy Long nonchalantly tells Jericho he has a shot at Rey at “Extreme Rules” and that Rey was just in his office talking stipulations. So I guess Rey’s … not … done with … him? Really bad continuity. It took, like, 15 minutes to undo it all. Unacceptable.
Michelle McCool beat Gail Kim (who has lost, what, every match but one since coming back to WWE?) for No. 1 contender spot at Melina. Oh, Melina had a promo before this match that was pre-alcohol shit stomach ache bad. Just awful. Worst part of the show by far. Still it was better than everything on Raw.
Finally, Hardy beat Edge in the main for the right to pick the stips for “Extreme Rules.” He picks a ladder match, and Edge cowers in fear, for he doesn’t know how to do one of these … ladder matches, you called them? Come on. He’s had tons of these. Shouldn’t he have smiled, knowing he’s done this before? Whatever.
So who won that NBA game last night?
– Brian